Manchester United went into the summer needing a midfield and came out with three of them. Carlos Baleba from Brighton, Youri Tielemans from Aston Villa and Andrey Santos from Chelsea all arrived before the window shut on Thursday.
Three signings in one area of the pitch is either decisiveness or panic, and you usually cannot tell which until Christmas. What is clear is that United have decided the middle of their team was the thing holding everything else back.
Baleba is the one that will define the window
Brighton did not want to sell. They rarely do, and they rarely have to. Baleba has spent three seasons on the south coast turning into the sort of midfielder every big club claims to be looking for, physical enough to protect a back four and comfortable enough on the ball to start attacks himself.
He is also 22, which is the part United will point to when anyone asks about the fee. This is a signing meant to still be paying off in 2030.
Tielemans brings the thing they were missing
Experience, mostly. Tielemans has played nearly everywhere that matters, has a Premier League winner's medal for an FA Cup final goal at Leicester, and knows exactly how a season in this league unfolds. Aston Villa let him go, which raised eyebrows.
He is not the athlete Baleba is. He does not need to be. In a midfield three where somebody else covers the ground, Tielemans is the one who slows the game down when United are ahead and picks the pass when they are chasing.
Andrey Santos and the Chelsea pipeline
The Brazilian arrives from Chelsea, where he had been on the books for years without ever nailing down a permanent role in the first team. Clubs have been watching him closely on loan and the reports have been consistently good.
If he works, United have a young midfielder at a fraction of the cost of Baleba. If he does not, he is the least expensive part of the rebuild.
The obvious risk
- Three new midfielders means at least one starts the season on the bench
- New signings need time to learn each other, and United do not have a gentle fixture list
- The players moved on to make room are not coming back if this goes wrong
United have spent big in a single position before and watched it produce a squad full of players who do not fit together. That is the fear here.
Verdict
On paper, this is the most coherent United window in years. They identified one problem and threw resources at it instead of buying a forward because a forward was available. Whether it works comes down to whether the coaching gets three individuals playing as a unit.
Premier League clubs spent a record 3.46 billion pounds this summer. United's share of it went into one part of the pitch. We will know by December whether that was the right call.
More from SoloScore: Manchester United news, transfers and match analysis all season.
0 Comments