England play Spain at Wembley on Saturday evening, and the fixture carries a particular sting. Three months ago these two were supposed to meet in a World Cup final. Spain got there. England lost to Argentina in the semi-final, having led with fifteen minutes to go.
It would also have been a rematch of the Euro 2024 final, which England lost to the same opponent. Jess Anderson's piece for BBC Sport pulls the thread properly: in their past 15 matches against sides ranked in Fifa's top ten, England have won six. That is the number the whole argument hangs on.
Six wins, and where they came from
Break those six down and they thin out fast. Three came at major tournaments — the Euro semi-finals of 2021 and 2024, against Denmark and the Netherlands, and the third-place match against France at this summer's World Cup. That France win was Thomas Tuchel's first against top-ten opposition as England manager. His first against anybody in the top twenty came in the tournament opener against Croatia.
Of the other three, two were Euro qualifiers against an Italy side already falling away, and one was a Nations League match against Belgium six years ago. So the honest reading is that England have beaten two genuinely elite sides in competitive knockout football in five years, and both times it took them to a final they then lost.
The World Cup record is starker. England have gone out every single time they have met a top-ten nation in the knockout stages since 1998 — seven times from seven. In their last ten World Cup matches against top-ten opposition, the only win came against Argentina in the 2002 group stage. And when they have played the reigning world champions at a World Cup, they have lost all four: Uruguay in 1954, Brazil in 1962, France in 2022, Argentina this summer.
Where the ball goes
The possession figures point at the same thing from another angle. England's three lowest possession shares in those 15 games all came in the matches that decided something: 35.8% against Argentina in the World Cup semi-final, 34.9% against Spain in the Euro 2024 final, 42.1% against Italy in the 2020 final. Against the best teams, England do not have the ball, and they have not found a version of themselves that works without it.
Alex Howell's analysis for the BBC traces the pattern back through tournaments. The Euro 2020 last-16 win over Germany was real, but Germany were in transition and outside the top ten at the time. Italy beat England in that final after England took the lead, dropped deep and gave the ball away. In Qatar, England were largely the better side against France and still went out, on a missed Kane penalty and French know-how. At Euro 2024 they needed a last-gasp Ollie Watkins goal to beat the Netherlands and never laid a glove on Spain.
Kane's answer
England's record scorer, now on 85 international goals, was asked by BBC Radio 5 Live what the missing piece is. His answer was not tactical.
"I think it's just in those biggest moments, still being ourselves," Kane said. "The Argentina game was so hard to take, because we had a mindset of going to win the tournament, win in our way and our style, and if we lose trying to do that then we will take that. The Argentina game was maybe the first game we tried 'not to lose' in the last 30 minutes and then we ended up losing anyway."
He drew on Bayern Munich, where he has 152 goals in 154 games and two Bundesliga titles. "You don't fear anyone," the 33-year-old said. "You go and be yourself, if a team beats you, shake their hand after and say well done. You have an identity that you keep throughout." Tuchel has said he may have to embrace the chaos; Anthony Gordon has argued England should lean into their traditional direct game. Two different answers to the same problem, and Saturday night is the next time anyone finds out which of them works.
The numbers: Six wins in England's last 15 matches against Fifa top-ten sides. Eliminated in all seven World Cup knockout ties against top-ten opposition since 1998. One win in their last ten World Cup games against top-ten teams (Argentina, 2002 group stage). Beaten by the reigning world champions on all four meetings at a World Cup: Uruguay 4-2 (1954), Brazil 3-1 (1962), France 2-1 (2022), Argentina 2-1 (2026). Lowest possession in the 15-game sample: 35.8% v Argentina, 34.9% v Spain, 42.1% v Italy. Harry Kane has 85 England goals and 152 in 154 Bayern Munich appearances. England host Spain at Wembley in their Nations League opener on Saturday 26 September. Source: BBC Sport (Jess Anderson and Alex Howell).
0 Comments