Ten games is not much. It is barely a quarter of a season, and every manager in the bottom three will say so this week. The numbers say something less comfortable. BBC Sport statistician Chris Collinson has gone back through every 20-team Premier League campaign, all 31 of them since 1995-96, and found that in 19 of those seasons only one of the three worst sides after 10 matches managed to stay up.
That is the backdrop for Crystal Palace, Sunderland and Manchester United, who fill the last three places in that order from the bottom. Palace and United both go into the weekend with new managers, Thomas Frank at Selhurst Park and Mauricio Pochettino at Old Trafford. Sunderland have stuck with Regis Le Bris.
What 31 seasons say about the bottom three
Collinson counted 93 teams who were in the bottom three on record after 10 games. Forty-one survived and 52 went down, a survival rate of 44%. Two or more of the three have escaped in only 10 seasons, and not once in the last eight. The most recent was 2017-18, when all three got out. That clean sweep has happened twice. So has the opposite, all three relegated.
There is one line in the research that United supporters will not enjoy. The club sitting 18th at this stage has been relegated in each of the past six seasons. United are 18th. This is also the first time they have been in the bottom three after 10 games of a Premier League season, which tells you how strange the table looks.
Why Palace have been here before
Palace are bottom after 10 games for the third time, and the previous two ended well. In 2013-14 Tony Pulis replaced Ian Holloway and took them to 11th. In 2017-18 Roy Hodgson replaced Frank de Boer and they finished 11th again. Frank's appointment follows the same script: a poor start, an early change, a manager with a record of organising a side quickly.
Sunderland have a precedent of their own. The only other time they and Palace were the bottom two at this point was that same 2013-14 season, and Gus Poyet kept the Black Cats up with a late run. Nobody at the Stadium of Light would choose to rely on that again.
A table tighter than it has been in 24 years
Here is the part that cuts the other way. Palace have seven points, the most a bottom club has had after 10 games for 24 years. Sunderland's eight is the best total for a side in 19th for 16 years. Tottenham, in 11th, have 12. So five points cover the entire bottom half, the smallest gap at this stage since 2002-03, and only nine separate Palace from Chelsea in fifth.
That compression drags other clubs in. Bournemouth were ninth with 13 points after 10 games in 2019-20 and still went down on the final day. Manchester City had 14 at the same stage in 2000-01 and were relegated under Joe Royle, which remains the record. And 2002-03, the last season that looked like this one, is the year West Ham went down with 42 points. Forty may not be enough this time.
For United the ceiling matters as much as the floor. No team in the bottom three after 10 matches has finished higher than eighth; Bolton, Tottenham and Everton all managed that. Pochettino's first job is Liverpool away on Sunday. History gives him roughly a coin toss of staying up and almost no chance of a top-six finish, though with this table I would not bet much on history.
Table context: After 10 games Crystal Palace are 20th with seven points, Sunderland 19th with eight and Manchester United 18th. Tottenham are 11th on 12 points. Since 1995-96, 41 of the 93 teams in the bottom three after 10 games have survived (44%). Figures from BBC Sport analysis by Chris Collinson.
0 Comments