England's three most decisive players all earn their living somewhere else. Harry Kane is at Bayern Munich and holds the Ballon d'Or. Jude Bellingham is at Real Madrid and has never kicked a ball in the Premier League. Anthony Gordon swapped Newcastle for Barcelona in the summer. When Thomas Tuchel named his initial 25-man squad for this month's games, seven of them played abroad.
That would have sounded absurd a decade ago. BBC Sport's Alex Howell has been asking why it's happening, and the answers from inside the England camp are more interesting than the usual line about money and sunshine.
Gordon and the respect question
Gordon was the bluntest. In an ITV interview he said people in England rated him because he was quick and pressed hard, but never gave him credit for his quality or his football brain. Only team-mates seemed to notice. At Barcelona, playing a different way next to Lamine Yamal and Raphinha, he feels those parts of his game are finally being seen.
He has three goals and five assists in 15 appearances in all competitions for his new club. He was also one of England's best players at the World Cup: both assists for Kane's goals against DR Congo in the last 32, a penalty won against Mexico in the last 16, and the goal that put England in front in the semi-final against Argentina. Kane says he is showing he belongs at the highest level and is relishing being one of the main men.
There's an awkward truth in what Gordon says. The Premier League is the richest and probably the hardest league in the world, yet it does not hand out individual status the way Madrid, Barcelona or Munich do. Since Cristiano Ronaldo won the Ballon d'Or in 2008, Rodri in 2024 is the only winner who was playing in England at the time. The last Englishman to win it while at an English club was Michael Owen in 2001.
What the FA thinks
You might expect the Football Association to be nervous about its best players leaving. It isn't. Technical director John McDermott told the BBC there are 43 English players on the FA's radar at European clubs and called that a "huge positive".
His reasoning is practical. A player abroad gets Champions League or European football without, as he put it, having to bang out 55 games, and that leaves time for gym work and technical training that the English calendar squeezes out. He was a believer in this even when he worked at Tottenham, because a new dressing room and a new language force a young player to adapt and stop him getting comfortable. He remembers Kieran Trippier coming back from Atletico Madrid noticeably tighter on the ball.
McDermott did push back a little on Gordon's point, saying he thinks the winger was always respected. And he was careful not to talk down the domestic route. Jarell Quansah and Jobe Bellingham, both now in Germany, came through the EFL first. There is no magic formula, he said.
The number that should worry people
The trend started in earnest when a teenage Jadon Sancho joined Borussia Dortmund in 2017. What has changed is who is going. It used to be youngsters who couldn't get a game. Now it's the captain and the two biggest attacking talents.
McDermott let slip the figure that matters most: English-qualified players make up only about 26 or 27 per cent of those playing in the Premier League. He wants more in the pipeline. Set that beside the exodus and you can see both halves of the story. English players are good enough to be wanted by the biggest clubs in Europe, and they are also finding fewer places at home.
Tuchel isn't bothered where they play. He said Bellingham and Kane were decisive at the World Cup and he sees no reason that will change, that Gordon has now stepped up as the third, and that a Premier League player can do the same. Dominic Calvert-Lewin, the Leeds striker, thinks the returning players bring something new into the group every time. England reached the World Cup semi-finals in the summer, only the third time in their history. It's hard to say the travelling has hurt them.
Key facts: Seven of England's initial 25-man squad play outside England, including Harry Kane (Bayern Munich), Jude Bellingham (Real Madrid) and Anthony Gordon, 25 (Barcelona). The FA is tracking 43 English players at European clubs. About 26-27% of Premier League players are English-qualified, according to FA technical director John McDermott. Source: Alex Howell for BBC Sport.
0 Comments