Michael Carrick walked a lap of Old Trafford on Sunday evening, clapping a crowd that was singing his name, and he knew exactly what it looked like. Manchester United had just lost 3-0 at home to Bournemouth. Eight games without a win, the worst run since 2015-16, and two heavy defeats in a week after the 4-1 loss at Como in the Champions League. BBC Sport reports that the club's bosses are in serious talks about his future.
A Result Nobody Could Spin
United have won one of their eight Premier League matches this season. They sit 16th, 14 points off the top, and haven't won a top-flight game since beating Ipswich 5-2 on 30 August. Carrick, 45, took interim charge in January after Ruben Amorim left, then got the job permanently in May once United finished third and booked a Champions League place. Since the permanent appointment he has won just two league games.
He gave the dressing room plenty to talk about before kick-off, too. Bruno Fernandes had questioned the tactics after Como, so Carrick left his captain on the bench against Bournemouth and handed the armband to Harry Maguire. Lisandro Martinez had already apologised for remarks about the club's hierarchy, saying he expected more investment and more from technical director Jason Wilcox. Asked afterwards whether he'd be in the dugout at Chelsea next Saturday, Carrick said he didn't know. "See what happens," he told BBC Sport.
Cheers For Him, Boos For Everyone Else
The sound inside the ground told its own story. Supporters chanted Carrick's name, a man who made 464 appearances for the club across 12 years, then turned on the players the moment he disappeared down the tunnel. The booing carried on until Diogo Dalot, the last man off, had left the pitch. Anti-Glazer and anti-Jim Ratcliffe songs started inside the first minute, and a "Standards" banner showing Bryan Robson, Eric Cantona and Roy Keane hung from the Stretford End.
"It wasn't a farewell from me," Carrick told Sky Sports, saying he had mixed emotions. Maguire insisted the players were fully behind him but added that "as individuals, we're not playing well enough." Gary Neville was less comforting. He said fans sing for Carrick because they know what's coming, and that Omar Berrada and Wilcox were probably about to make a decision that would disgust supporters but was probably necessary.
Why Sacking Him May Not Settle Anything
That's the uncomfortable part for the people upstairs. BBC Sport's reading of the afternoon was that a new face in the dugout won't calm a stand that is angry about far more than results. The Glazers' debt has grown to more than £1.15bn according to the club's latest accounts, with £852m paid in interest, per Swiss Ramble. There's a ticket-touting investigation the fan groups have condemned, plans for a 100,000-seat stadium, and a chief executive and director of football who were both at Manchester City before. Wilcox was booed as he left the ground almost two hours after the final whistle.
A third managerial dismissal in three seasons, after Erik ten Hag in October 2024 and Amorim in January, wouldn't reflect well on anybody. My read is that Carrick probably isn't going to survive a trip to Chelsea if the performance looks anything like Sunday's. But the stand has made clear who it holds responsible, and it isn't only him.
Match facts: Manchester United 0-3 Bournemouth, Premier League, Old Trafford, Sunday 25 October 2026. United: 16th, one win in eight league games, 14 points behind the leaders. Next: Chelsea away, Saturday.
0 Comments