Most of the reaction to Manchester City's guilty verdict has come from people who want something back. Wayne Rooney has gone the other way. Speaking on Stick To United, the club's record scorer said he would not accept a retrospective Premier League medal for 2011-12 if the title were taken off City and handed to the runners-up, and the reason he gave has nothing to do with City at all.
"We threw it away"
"I wouldn't really feel comfortable accepting another Premier League medal, if I'm being honest," Rooney said. "I don't think we deserve it, we didn't do enough that season to win the league. I think we were six or seven points clear with four or five games to go and we threw it away."
That is a harsher account of 2011-12 than most United supporters give. The season is remembered for Sergio Aguero's winner against Queens Park Rangers on the final day and for the goal difference that separated the two clubs, which frames it as something that happened to United rather than something United did. Rooney's version is the opposite. The lead was there and his team lost it, and no ruling by a disciplinary panel fourteen years later changes what happened on the pitch.
Sympathy for the players in the other dressing room
He went further, and this is the part his former team-mates have not been saying. Asked about the City squad of that era, Rooney said he had put himself in their position. "They're players, they're doing everything they can to try and win the Premier League title and in their mind they have done it," he said. "If those players have no understanding of what is going on above them, if that happened to me... I would be absolutely devastated."
On whether City should lose the titles, he was willing to say yes. "Should they get it stripped for what the owners have done? Yeah maybe," he said. "But I wouldn't feel comfortable accepting it." He finished with a line that reads like a closed door: "I'm happy with the five I've won. I wouldn't want this one."
Five is enough, apparently.
De Gea and Ferdinand went the other way
The contrast with the rest of that United dressing room is stark. David de Gea posted on X in the days after the verdict asking how many Premier League titles he had actually won. Rio Ferdinand said a new medal would be "added to the cabinet" and then turned on his old England colleague Joleon Lescott, joking that "next time Joleon's on, he better bring my b****y medal" and adding that anyone found guilty should give the medals back.
None of it is in anyone's gift yet. The Premier League has not said what the sanction will be, and stripping titles from a decade-old season would be without precedent in English football. Until that call is made, the medal argument stays exactly where Rooney left it: a conversation between former players about a trophy nobody has offered them.
Context: Manchester City were found guilty over their financial rule breaches, with sanctions yet to be determined. The 2011-12 Premier League was decided on goal difference on the final day, Sergio Aguero scoring a late winner against QPR. Wayne Rooney won five Premier League titles with Manchester United and remains the club's record goalscorer. His comments were made on the Stick To United podcast and reported by Goal on 29 September 2026.
0 Comments